{
  "reviewId": "REL-29-RECEIPT-REVIEW-20261102-R1",
  "task": "LEGACY-MEETING-EXPERT-01 / MP-LIST-REFRESH-01",
  "redmine": 29,
  "reviewedAt": "2026-11-02T01:25:41+08:00",
  "mode": "existing Operations receipt applicability review only",
  "sourceIndex": "release/index.md",
  "sourceReceipt": "release/receipt.json",
  "defaultPwd": "/Users/gexiaowei/Documents/work/mindsetech/ndb",
  "checks": [
    {
      "id": "REL-SOURCE",
      "conclusion": "Supported",
      "claim": "批准28文件、必要版本/批准元数据及原功能证据适用",
      "sources": [
        "package.md",
        "candidate.json",
        "operations-preflight.json",
        "source-commits.json"
      ],
      "review": "来源记录8/4/16文件hash匹配，三个sourceCommit有归属；只读复用53开发+13QA，未重算28代码hash、未运行功能测试；真实双会话未测已由最新发布授权明确接受，不升级为Pass。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-BACKEND",
      "conclusion": "Supported",
      "claim": "生产Backend1.20.15、0011迁移、同DB及五服务同镜像",
      "sources": [
        "backend-production-git.json",
        "cnb-transport-diagnostic.json",
        "backend-preflight.json",
        "backend-runtime.json"
      ],
      "review": "精确f1aadbdf与v1.20.15 CI success一致；旧1.20.14预检仅新0011 CreateModel/AddConstraint；新runtime1.20.15、8文件hash匹配、0011 OK/表存在/剩余计划空；三处DB指纹一致；5服务记录同imageId，不扩称五服务全量健康测试。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-SNAPSHOT",
      "conclusion": "Supported",
      "claim": "同批准SHA43公开快照preview/apply/提交后读回，四类增量0",
      "sources": [
        "manifest-recovery.json",
        "snapshot-import-preview.json",
        "snapshot-import-receipt.json"
      ],
      "review": "恢复/preview/apply均同dd5d409c…a8428；43 create/43 committed readback，公开字段和目标映射匹配；保护前后Task6530/Cost6686/MeetingExpert0/Profile73一致、增量全0；只快照INSERT，未补5条无目标、无热点写/新备份。源文件恢复与导入未再导出源数据是不同动作，不将sourcePersistedToFile=false误作原批准manifest不存在。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-BFF-STAGING",
      "conclusion": "Supported",
      "claim": "staging0.1.2-beta.0实际版本及编译适配",
      "sources": [
        "bff-staging-git.json",
        "bff-staging-ci.json",
        "bff-staging-runtime.json"
      ],
      "review": "b2533f81候选/tag/CI/runtime revision一致，实际package0.1.2-beta.0及编译历史快照适配存在；运行镜像staging alias与CI语义一致，旧version-tag支持脚本guard失败保留。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-BFF-PRODUCTION",
      "conclusion": "Supported",
      "claim": "production0.1.2及固定tag修正最终生效",
      "sources": [
        "bff-production-git.json",
        "bff-production-ci.json",
        "bff-production-runtime-diagnostic.json",
        "bff-production-fixed-tag-deploy.json",
        "coolify-transport-diagnostic.json",
        "bff-production-fixed-tag-api.json",
        "bff-production-runtime.json"
      ],
      "review": "旧实际v0.1.1的诊断与CLI mutation失败保留；context/auth只读核验后，官方PATCH仅docker_registry_image_tag与POST deploy各200；最终v0.1.2实际revision27f4b09a等于批准候选，编译适配存在。CI成功本身不当作运行生效；未改原生产15秒/测试30秒上游参数。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-MINI-UPLOAD",
      "conclusion": "SupportedDevelopmentUploadOnly",
      "claim": "测试robot1及生产robot2的1.0.8开发版上传",
      "sources": [
        "mini-prepared-git.json",
        "mini-staging-ci.json",
        "mini-staging-upload.json",
        "mini-production-git.json",
        "mini-production-ci.json",
        "mini-production-upload.json"
      ],
      "review": "ea3436d7/robot1/test与1c10796b/robot2/production分别精确对应CI候选，上传开发版stage success，built API隔离guard已核，Mini请求20秒；两份upload均明确未提审、未发布。不能标小程序线上已更新。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-GIT-CLOSURE",
      "conclusion": "SupportedAtOpsReceiptTime",
      "claim": "三仓clean main与实时remote main相同，无额外Git操作",
      "sources": [
        "receipt.json backendGitClosure",
        "backend-production-git.json",
        "bff-mini-git-closure.json"
      ],
      "review": "Backend closure passed、local/live main同f1aadbdf，生产Git来源clean=true；BFF/Mini显式clean、无进行中Git操作、本地/实时remote main同27f4b09a/1c10796b。仅审Ops记录时点，不重跑Git或推断之后永不漂移。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-WECHAT",
      "conclusion": "Waiting/NotReleased",
      "claim": "微信登录、提审与正式发布外部前置",
      "sources": [
        "browser-replacement.json",
        "wechat-platform-state.json",
        "mini-production-upload.json"
      ],
      "review": "唯一替代Space1/p3已handOff用户，源状态为登录前且扫码区未显示二维码；reviewSubmitted=false/published=false。未操作浏览器、未再次催扫码。该项不是Fail，正式小程序版本尚不能宣称生效。"
    },
    {
      "id": "REL-BACKEND-STAGING",
      "conclusion": "NotExecutedScopeBlocked",
      "claim": "Backend测试环境本项未部署",
      "sources": [
        "backend-staging-blocker.json",
        "package.md"
      ],
      "review": "preview两条无关销售提交保留，未创建beta3/推送/部署测试Backend；最新授权准许停止该扩范围动作并独立推进生产。不能将BFF staging和Mini测试上传概括为整套Backend测试部署已完成。"
    }
  ],
  "supportedEvidenceChecks": 7,
  "externalStatus": "Waiting/NotReleased",
  "backendStaging": "NotExecutedScopeBlocked",
  "missingRequiredSourceEvidence": [],
  "functionalTestsExecuted": 0,
  "functionalPassCountAdded": 0,
  "priorDeveloper53AndQA13Reused": true,
  "previousDualSessionResultPromoted": false,
  "liveEnvironmentCIPageOrGitQueries": 0,
  "browserCredentialDBOrEnvironmentOperations": 0,
  "deviationsPreserved": [
    "operations-deviation.json",
    "backend-runtime-initial-failure.json",
    "bff-staging-runtime-initial-guard.json",
    "bff-production-fixed-tag-deploy.json"
  ],
  "qaWritesOnly": [
    "release/qa-review/receipt-review.md",
    "release/qa-review/review-results.json",
    "release/qa-review/writeback-receipt.json",
    "task index.md"
  ],
  "overall": "completed claims supported by same Ops receipt; Mini formal release remains Waiting/NotReleased"
}